Remember penny candy? If you miss it, head to Geneva's Sweet Nostalgia, which stockpiles old-time favorites like flying saucers, malted milk tablets, chocolate cigarettes and cinnamon toothpicks. Stock up on Boston Baked Beans (ahh, candy-coated peanuts that masquerade as legumes), bubble gum cigars, hotdog gum, candy buttons, fun dip and candy necklaces. Revisiting your youth has never been so simple, thanks to Sugar Babies, Pixy Stix and Pop Rocks. Inflation hasn’t affected this place, so $25 should amply purchase enough candy to give to the kiddies on Halloween or fill the bowls for your retro costume party.

Centerstage Reviewer: Shelly Burton